The short version: plant protein tests worse than whey for lead and cadmium — but chocolate flavouring tests worse than either, by a bigger margin than the protein source does. No Australian or American authority sets a heavy-metal limit for protein powder, so nothing tested was unlawful. And the certification most people trust applies a lead ceiling twenty times higher than the number that triggers a warning label in California.
A note on fairness before anything else: every finding below is about specific lots tested at a specific time, not about a brand in general. That distinction matters legally and it matters factually, because contamination in plant protein is driven by the agricultural origin of a particular batch of raw material.
What the testing actually found
Consumer Reports, October 2025
Published 14 October 2025. 23 products — plant-based, whey, and beef-based, powders and ready-to-drink shakes. Two to four distinct lots per product, purchased over three months from November 2024, tested for lead, cadmium, arsenic and total protein. (Consumer Reports did not name the laboratory.)
They compared against their own "level of concern" of 0.5 µg of lead per day, taken from California's Prop 65 threshold and described as the most protective standard available.
Two per-product figures we could verify from independent sources:
| Product (as tested) | Category | Lead per serve | Cadmium per serve |
|---|---|---|---|
| Naked Nutrition Vegan Mass Gainer | plant | 7.7 µg | — |
| Huel Black Edition | plant | 6.3 µg | 9.2 µg |
Aggregate findings: about 70% exceeded 120% of CR's concern level. Of the 23, 16 exceeded 0.5 µg of lead, four exceeded 2.2 µg, two delivered 72% and 88% of the daily amount considered safe in pregnancy, two exceeded the cadmium threshold and one exceeded arsenic.
Plant-based averaged about nine times the lead of dairy or whey, and about twice the beef-based products.
The brand responses, which deserve weight
Naked Nutrition disputed the methodology on serving size, pointing out that its Vegan Mass Gainer serving is 315 g against 30–50 g for a typical powder. That is a substantive and legitimate objection — a per-serve comparison across a six- to ten-fold serving-size range is not like-for-like. On a per-gram basis Naked's product is not the worst in the set, which arguably makes Huel Black Edition's 6.3 µg in a conventional serving the more meaningful number.
Optimum Nutrition declined to comment. Huel did not address the cadmium finding. BSN, Dymatize, Jocko Fuel, Muscle Milk, Owyn, PlantFusion and Transparent Labs did not respond.
Clean Label Project
2018 round: 134 products across roughly 53 brands, tested by Ellipse Analytics. About 75% of plant-based powders had measurable lead against about 10% of whey-based products above health guidelines, and none of the egg-based powders contained lead. Certified organic products averaged about twice the heavy metals. Separately, 55% had measurable BPA and 28 of 134 exceeded double the regulatory limit.
2024–25 round, published 9 January 2025: 160 products from 70 brands, 35,862 individual tests, ICP-MS for metals.
- 47% exceeded Prop 65 thresholds for toxic metals; 21% exceeded double the Prop 65 lead level
- Organic versus non-organic: 3× more lead, 2× more cadmium
- Plant versus whey: 3× more lead, 5× more cadmium
- Chocolate versus vanilla: 4× more lead and 110× more cadmium
That last line is the single most striking figure in the entire body of evidence, and we'll come back to it.
No mean, median or per-serving figures are published in the whitepaper, which is itself a fair methodological criticism.
The criticism of Clean Label Project, which you should read alongside its findings
The industry response was not merely defensive. Andrea Wong of the Council for Responsible Nutrition: "Detection of contaminants does not inherently equate to a health risk." Duffy MacKay of the Consumer Healthcare Products Association noted the report "has not been peer-reviewed nor published in a scientific journal, and the full testing methods have not been provided," and that it uses the Prop 65 level "to call out products" while failing "to provide context." Daniel Fabricant of the Natural Products Association called the study "a sham."
And there is a documented conflict worth stating plainly. In September 2020, Pharmavite sued Clean Label Project in the US District Court for the Central District of California under RICO, the Lanham Act and California's Unfair Competition Law, alleging CLP "uses the cover of its nonprofit status to pressure companies into paying sizable fees to acquire the organization's certifications." Among the co-defendants was Ellipse Analytics — the same laboratory that performed both CLP protein powder studies.
Those remain allegations; we could not establish the outcome of the suit. But a reader weighing CLP's findings should know the laboratory and the certification business were named together in a case alleging the scheme was a protection racket.
The Texas Attorney General investigation
Opened 8 June 2026, industry-wide. No companies have been named — that is the most important fact in this section, and no reader should infer that any particular brand is under investigation.
The legal theory is the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act — a consumer-deception theory, not a product-safety one. The state is examining whether companies "falsely marketed or misrepresented the safety and contents of their products." It is not alleging the products are unlawfully contaminated, because there is no US limit to breach.
As of late June 2026 the Natural Products Association had met the AG's office and reported that it was "not clear whether the state has a litigative target."
Why plant protein tests worse
Rice and cadmium: it's transporter biology, not flooding
A widely repeated explanation has the soil chemistry backwards. **Flooding a paddy immobilises cadmium; draining it mobilises cadmium.** Under flooded anaerobic conditions, sulfate is reduced to sulfide and cadmium precipitates as highly insoluble CdS, while iron plaque forms on rice roots and further restricts uptake. When the paddy is drained and aerated, sulfides oxidise, pH falls, the iron plaque dissolves, and cadmium is remobilised into pore water. This is why water-saving "alternate wetting and drying" regimes increase grain cadmium, and why continuous flooding during grain fill is a recommended mitigation.
The real reason rice accumulates cadmium is a transporter. Rice has no cadmium-specific transporter; it takes cadmium up by molecular mimicry through OsNRAMP5, its manganese transporter, which rice expresses far more highly than wheat or maize express their equivalents — and then loads it efficiently into grain via the phloem.
Cocoa is a separate and larger problem, and the two metals arrive differently
This is the mechanistic insight that makes the 110× cadmium figure make sense.
Cadmium in cocoa is taken up from soil by the cacao tree and accumulates in the bean as it grows, with the highest levels in volcanic soils — hence certain Latin American origins.
Lead in cocoa is almost entirely post-harvest surface contamination. Rankin et al. (Environ Health Perspect, 2005) found raw cocoa beans at ≤0.5 ng/g — among the lowest of any natural food — while manufactured cocoa reached 230 ng/g and chocolate products 70 ng/g. Lead isotope signatures matched global industrial aerosols rather than farm soil: the contamination happens during fermentation and sun-drying, when cocoa shells adsorb atmospheric lead, and during shipping and manufacture.
The practical consequence for a buyer: flavour choice may matter more than protein source. CLP's chocolate-versus-vanilla multiples (4× lead, 110× cadmium) are larger than its plant-versus-whey multiples (3× and 5×). Choosing unflavoured or vanilla is plausibly the single highest-leverage change available, and it costs nothing.
Why whey and egg test cleaner
Whey is a by-product of milk, and the cow functions as a biological filter — lactating cattle transfer very little ingested cadmium or lead into milk. Both metals partition preferentially into kidney and liver, which is precisely why Australia's own contaminant standard sets its highest cadmium limits for offal (kidney 2.5 mg/kg, liver 1.25 mg/kg) against 0.05 mg/kg for muscle meat. Egg protein tested cleanest of all in the 2018 CLP round.
The threshold problem
There is no single "safe" number, and consumers are badly served by that. Here is every figure that gets quoted, what it actually is, and where it comes from.
| Standard | Lead | Cadmium | What it actually is |
|---|---|---|---|
| California Prop 65 MADL | 0.5 µg/day | 4.1 µg/day | A warning-label trigger, not a safety limit. Derived by taking a no-observed-effect level for reproductive toxicity and dividing by a 1,000-fold safety factor. Exceeding it creates a labelling duty. |
| US FDA Interim Reference Levels | 2.2 µg/day (children)<br>8.8 µg/day (women of childbearing age) | — | Back-calculated from the CDC blood lead reference value of 3.5 µg/dL with a 10× safety factor. Not enforceable, and the FDA sets no lead limit for dietary supplements at all. |
| USP <2232> | 10 µg/day | 5 µg/day | Permitted daily exposure for dietary supplements. Inorganic arsenic 15 µg/day, total mercury 15 µg/day. |
| NSF/ANSI 173 | 10 µg/day | 4.1 µg/day | Twenty times the Prop 65 lead threshold. Note cadmium is identical to Prop 65 — the gap is lead-specific. |
| EFSA | no value | — | EFSA withdrew its tolerable weekly intake for lead because "a threshold for these effects could not be identified." It moved to a margin-of-exposure approach. Reference point for developmental neurotoxicity: BMDL₀₁ of 0.5 µg/kg bw/day. |
| FSANZ Schedule 19 (Australia) | none for protein powder | none for protein powder | See below. |
The Australian situation, which is the real finding here
Schedule 19 of the Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code sets no maximum level for protein powders, protein supplements, formulated supplementary sports foods or dietary supplements. It sets limits only for specific commodity categories.
So an Australian protein powder cannot "breach" a heavy-metal limit, because none applies to it.
What is regulated are the ingredients. Lead: cereals, pulses and legumes 0.2 mg/kg; fruit and vegetables 0.1 mg/kg. Cadmium: rice 0.1 mg/kg; wheat 0.1 mg/kg; peanuts 0.5 mg/kg; leafy and root vegetables 0.1 mg/kg; chocolate and cocoa products 0.5 mg/kg.
The gap is the whole point: the inputs are regulated, the concentrate is not — and concentrating protein from those inputs concentrates whatever metals they carried.
Note also that most protein powder in Australia is sold as a food, not a therapeutic good. It has no AUST L number, and the absence of one means nothing. Only sports supplements caught by the TGA's November 2020 declaration — those in medicinal dosage forms or making therapeutic claims — become listed medicines.
Why a product can pass NSF and still need a Prop 65 warning
Because the two numbers answer different questions.
NSF/ANSI 173's 10 µg/day is a toxicological tolerable-intake figure for a supplement. Prop 65's 0.5 µg/day is a litigation safe harbour built by dividing a no-effect level by 1,000.
A powder containing 6 µg of lead per serve is below NSF's ceiling (so it passes certification) and twelve times above the Prop 65 warning trigger (so it requires a warning) — simultaneously, with no contradiction and no scientific dispute.
Neither number is "the safe level." EFSA's position is that no safe level exists to be found.
One more thing for Australian readers: Prop 65 is a Californian statute with no legal force in Australia. You see those warnings here only as an artefact of US-labelled imports, and their absence on an Australian-labelled product tells you nothing at all.
How worried should you actually be?
Both ways, honestly.
The case for taking it seriously: the worst verified figure is 6.3 µg of lead in a conventional serving. Against the FDA's reference level of 8.8 µg/day for women of childbearing age, that is about 70% of a whole day's reference intake from one shake — consistent with CR's own statement that two products supplied 72% and 88% of the pregnancy-relevant daily amount. And every threshold above is a per-day figure while every test result is reported per serve, so two or three shakes a day multiplies exposure linearly with no cumulative limit anywhere in the system.
The case against panic: Australia's own Total Diet Study concluded that dietary lead exposure "for most Australian consumers was lower than levels found to be of negligible risk of causing adverse health effects," with risks "acceptably low," and that cadmium exposures presented "no public health and safety concerns for Australian consumers." The major dietary lead contributors it identified were water, soft drinks, baked goods, dried and tinned fruit, pork, deli meats, honey and chocolate — a protein shake joins a long list rather than dominating it.
(We were not able to retrieve the absolute µg/day exposure figures from the ATDS appendix tables, so we've reported FSANZ's conclusions rather than inventing a number.)
Historical context also helps: leaded petrol was phased out in Australia and children's blood lead levels have fallen dramatically since, so background exposure today is a small fraction of what anyone who grew up before the 1990s experienced.
Who should care most
- Pregnancy. The FDA's reference level for women of childbearing age is the relevant one, and two tested products delivered most of it in a single serve.
- Children and adolescents. The FDA's reference level for children is four times lower than for adults. EFSA could identify no threshold for lead's developmental neurotoxicity at all.
- Anyone drinking multiple servings daily, because all limits are per-day.
- Anyone stacking plant-based supplements — rice protein plus pea protein plus a greens powder plus cocoa is several plant-matrix cadmium and lead sources at once. No study we could find quantifies stacked exposure. That's an evidence gap, not a reassurance.
And here is something most Australians have never noticed. A protein powder sold under Standard 2.9.4 as a formulated supplementary sports food is already legally required to carry: "Not suitable for children under 15 years of age or pregnant women: Should only be used under medical or dietetic supervision." The warning the test results point toward is, for many products, already on the pack.
What the certifications actually cover
One common claim needs correcting: it is often said that sports certifications test only for banned substances, not contaminants. That is true for Informed Sport and Informed Choice. It is not true for NSF.
| Certification | What it tests | Heavy-metal limit |
|---|---|---|
| NSF/ANSI 173 | Label accuracy, GMP, and contaminants including heavy metals, pesticides, herbicides | Lead 10 µg/day — 20× Prop 65 |
| NSF Certified for Sport | Everything in NSF/ANSI 173 plus banned-substance screening | Same — lead 10 µg/day |
| Informed Sport (LGC) | Over 285 substances prohibited in sport. Every batch tested individually before release | None — banned substances only |
| Informed Choice (LGC) | Same banned-substance scope, but surveillance-based — periodic retail and blind sampling, not every batch | None |
| USP Verified | Identity, potency, GMP audit, plus USP <2232> contaminant limits | Lead 10 µg/day, cadmium 5 µg/day |
| Australian AUST L listing | Self-assessment against a permitted ingredient list. The TGA does not pre-test the product. | Not evidence of heavy-metal testing — and most protein powders are foods with no AUST L number anyway |
So the honest line on NSF Certified for Sport is not "it doesn't test metals." It's that it tests metals against a ceiling twenty times higher than the number that triggers a warning label in California.
The cross-cutting point: no certification on this list applies a lead limit at or below Prop 65's 0.5 µg/day. Buy the most heavily certified product on the shelf and you have bought a guarantee against 10 µg/day, not against detectable lead.
The Informed Sport versus Informed Choice distinction is also widely misunderstood and worth knowing: Sport is every-batch, pre-release; Choice is periodic surveillance. For an athlete subject to testing, that difference is the whole product.
What you can actually do
Ask for a certificate of analysis, and know what to look for. Five things:
- Batch-specific or "representative"? A representative CoA tells you nothing about the tub in your hand — and Consumer Reports found enough lot-to-lot variation to test two to four lots per product.
- Which metals? Lead, cadmium, inorganic arsenic and mercury should all appear. Inorganic arsenic specifically, not just total.
- Which laboratory, and is it independent of the brand?
- Limit of detection. "Not detected" is meaningless without one, and an LOD above 0.5 µg makes a pass uninformative.
- Units and basis. Micrograms per serve or mg/kg of powder — and what serving size is assumed. The Naked Nutrition objection is exactly this problem.
Choose vanilla or unflavoured over chocolate if cadmium is your concern. On CLP's numbers this is a bigger lever than switching protein source, and it's free.
Whey or egg over rice protein for daily high-volume use, on both CLP rounds and the CR data. (We found no study isolating pea protein's contribution specifically — it's implicated in the aggregate plant figures but not separately quantified.)
Rotate sources, and don't stack multiple plant-matrix supplements, since every threshold is per-day and cumulative exposure is unregulated.
If pregnant, or buying for a child or teenager, lead with the label: the mandated sports-food warning already says not suitable.
One important limitation for Australian readers
No Australian testing of these products has been published. Consumer Reports tested specific US lots bought in New York in late 2024, and Clean Label Project tested US-market products. Because plant protein contamination is driven by the agricultural origin of the raw material, an Australian tub of the same brand and flavour could differ materially — in either direction.
The CR and CLP results cannot be transferred to Australian-market stock. They tell you what to ask about. They do not tell you what's in the tub you own.
Frequently asked
Is there lead in protein powder? Measurable lead was found in most products tested by Consumer Reports in 2025 and Clean Label Project in 2018 and 2025. The highest verified figure in a conventional serving was 6.3 µg. Whether that matters depends entirely on which threshold you use — it is below every supplement-industry limit and more than twelve times California's warning trigger, and neither of those is a safety line.
Is plant protein worse than whey for heavy metals? On the testing, yes — Consumer Reports found plant-based averaged about nine times the lead of dairy-based, and Clean Label Project found three times the lead and five times the cadmium. The mechanism is real: rice takes up cadmium through its manganese transporter, and plant material generally carries whatever the soil held. But flavour matters more than you'd expect — chocolate products tested 110 times higher for cadmium than vanilla in the 2025 round.
Does NSF Certified for Sport mean no heavy metals? No. It does test for heavy metals, which many people don't realise — but its lead ceiling is 10 µg per day, twenty times California's 0.5 µg warning threshold. A product can hold the certification and still require a Prop 65 warning, with no contradiction.
Is protein powder regulated for heavy metals in Australia? Not directly. Schedule 19 of the Food Standards Code sets maximum contaminant levels for specific foods — rice, wheat, cocoa, vegetables, meat — but not for protein powders or supplements. The ingredients are regulated; the concentrate made from them is not.
Should pregnant women avoid protein powder? Many protein powders sold in Australia as formulated supplementary sports foods already carry a mandatory warning that they are not suitable for pregnant women or children under 15 without medical or dietetic supervision. The testing data give that existing warning more weight. Talk to your doctor or dietitian.
Last reviewed 1 October 2026. Every test result described relates to specific product lots tested at a specific time, not to brands in general, and no product described was shown to breach any applicable legal limit — because no heavy-metal limit applies to protein powder in either Australia or the United States. The Texas Attorney General's investigation has named no companies. Allegations against Clean Label Project are unresolved. This page is general information, not medical advice.