What the research found

A 2017 study evaluated 613 adults carrying a physician diagnosis of asthma using objective testing—spirometry, bronchial challenge tests, and medication withdrawal protocols. About one-third of participants showed no evidence of asthma when formally assessed. Some had never undergone objective testing at the time of initial diagnosis; they were diagnosed on symptoms and clinical exam alone. Within the group ultimately found not to have asthma, a small fraction had serious alternative conditions present—coronary artery disease, airway stenosis, interstitial lung disease, and other conditions—that had been labelled as asthma.

Asthma is particularly prone to diagnostic error because symptoms are episodic and overlap with many other conditions (heart disease, reflux, vocal cord dysfunction). Once a diagnosis enters the medical record, subsequent encounters may be filtered through that label, even when symptoms are absent or atypical. The study couldn't always distinguish true misdiagnosis from genuine remission, but the association between lack of initial objective testing and later exclusion of asthma was statistically significant.

Why it matters for you

If you're tracking respiratory symptoms, exercise capacity, or training tolerance in MyKine—especially if you've been diagnosed with asthma or reactive airway disease—this highlights the value of documentation. Objective tests like spirometry, VO₂ max assessment, or bronchial challenge leave an auditable record. If your symptoms have changed, resolved, or don't fit the original diagnosis, those test results become reference points for reassessment rather than relying on symptom recall alone.

More broadly, diagnostic anchoring affects how providers interpret your biomarkers and symptoms over time. If your chart says "asthma," a new provider seeing dyspnea or low oxygen saturation may not investigate alternative causes—metabolic issues, cardiac function, training-induced changes, or medication effects. Gathering and organizing your own medical records (test results, imaging, specialist reports) gives you and your physicians a clearer picture when protocols change or symptoms shift. This is especially relevant if you're modifying training volume, using performance-enhancing substances, or managing multiple health conditions simultaneously.

Caveats

  • Study design: Cross-sectional evaluation of a subset of diagnosed patients; cannot establish causation or distinguish remission from initial misdiagnosis in all cases
  • Selection and generalisability: Limited to asthma; rates of diagnostic error vary widely by condition, clinical setting, and healthcare system
  • Cognitive bias explanation: Speculative; the study documented outcomes, not clinician decision-making processes
  • Broader diagnostic error rate (5% annually): Estimated from observational studies, not a definitive population figure, and highly condition-dependent