The short version: monohydrate wins, and it isn't close. Every alternative form charges a premium for a claim no human trial supports, and two of them — HCl capsules and gummies — cost ten to fourteen times more per gram of actual creatine. The gummies have a further problem: when independent labs assayed them, several contained essentially none.


The number that decides most of this

Creatine salts are not pure creatine. The creatine is attached to something, and that something has mass.

Form% creatine by massGrams of product for 5 g creatine
Creatine anhydrous100%5.00 g
Creatine monohydrate87.9%5.69 g
Creatine HCl78.2%6.39 g
Creatine nitrate67.5%7.41 g
Creatine ethyl ester HCl67.0%7.46 g
Creatine pyruvate59.8%8.36 g
Di-creatine citrate57.7%8.67 g
Tri-creatine citrate40.6%12.3 g

These are stoichiometry, not estimates, and they're confirmed in the published literature (Jäger, Kreider et al., Nutrients 2022;14(5):1035). You can check it on an Australian label: Musashi's tub states "creatine monohydrate 5 g, equivalent to 4.4 g creatine" — 88%, exactly as the chemistry says.

Now apply it to how HCl is actually sold. HCl products commonly recommend 750 mg to 1.5 g a day, on the argument that better solubility means you need less. But 1.5 g of creatine HCl contains 1.17 g of creatine — under a quarter of a standard 5 g monohydrate dose. No trial has ever shown that saturates muscle, because no trial has measured muscle creatine after HCl at all.


Does any alternative form beat monohydrate?

Buffered creatine (Kre-Alkalyn)

**Jagim AR, Oliver JM, Sanchez A, et al. JISSN 2012;9:43.** n=36 resistance-trained men, 28 days, three arms: monohydrate (20 g load then 5 g), buffered at the manufacturer's recommended 1.5 g/day, and buffered at 20 g load then 5 g.

No significant difference in muscle creatine content (p=0.46), body composition, bench or leg press 1RM, or anaerobic power. The authors' conclusion: buffered creatine "did not promote greater changes than creatine monohydrate."

Creatine ethyl ester

**Spillane M, Schoch R, Cooke M, et al. JISSN 2009;6:6.** n=30, 48 days.

  • **Serum creatine was significantly lower in the ethyl ester group** than both placebo and monohydrate (p=0.007, p=0.005)
  • Serum creatinine roughly tripled — 0.95 mg/dL to 2.68 mg/dL by day 6 (p=0.001) — and stayed elevated, consistent with rapid degradation
  • No group differences in 1RM, power or body composition

One nuance worth stating accurately, because it's usually reported wrong: muscle total creatine did rise in the ethyl ester group, similarly to monohydrate. The honest verdict is that CEE is a worse-value, faster-degrading delivery vehicle with no performance advantage — not that it fails entirely.

Creatine HCl — the trials exist, and none shows superiority

Our expectation going in was that no head-to-head trial existed. That's not quite right. There are a few. They're small, none is dose-matched properly, and none has measured muscle creatine — which is the measurement that would settle it.

**Tayebi SM & Arazi H. Science & Sports 2020;35(5):e135–e141. n=36 trained men, 7 days, four arms: monohydrate 20 g/day, monohydrate 3 g/day, HCl 3 g/day, placebo. No significant between-group differences** on power, vigour or hormones (p>0.05). Only the 20 g monohydrate arm improved within-group. The authors conclude HCl "seems to have no positive effects on physical performance and hormonal status."

**de França E, Avelar B, Yoshioka C, et al. Food and Nutrition Sciences 2015 is the study HCl marketing cites. It's worth reading properly: 40 enrolled, 30 completed, group sizes of six to eight, body composition by skinfold, doses not creatine-matched, and the HCl supplied by a manufacturer. The headline claim that "only creatine HCl induced changes on body composition" rests on within-group pre-post significances. There were no significant between-group differences.**

The solubility argument

Creatine HCl genuinely is more water-soluble than monohydrate. That part is real chemistry.

But no study has shown that higher solubility in the glass produces higher plasma creatine, higher muscle creatine or better performance. The mechanistic reason it probably doesn't matter: monohydrate's oral bioavailability is already essentially complete, and stomach pH below 2.5 suppresses the creatine-to-creatinine conversion during transit.

The International Society of Sports Nutrition position stand puts it flatly: claims that other forms are "degraded to a lesser degree... or result in greater uptake to muscle are currently unfounded."

And micronised versus regular

Micronisation is particle-size reduction, nothing more. There is no head-to-head human trial of micronised versus standard monohydrate. The only real-world difference is how well it disperses in water. That's a texture preference, not a performance claim — and it's cheap, so it's a fine one to have.


Loading: does it do anything lasting?

**Hultman E, Söderlund K, Timmons JA, Cederblad G, Greenhaff PL. J Appl Physiol 1996;81(1):232–237** is the study that answers this, and it answers it cleanly.

GroupProtocolMuscle total creatine (mmol/kg dry matter)
1 (n=6)20 g/day × 6 days, then nothing123.4 → ~146 (day 7) → 139.2 (day 21) → back to ~123 by day 35
2 (n=9)20 g/day × 6 days, then 2 g/day119.5 → ~142 (day 7), maintained to day 35
3 (n=9)3 g/day, no loading121.8 → 136.5 (day 14) → 142.0 (day 29)

The authors' own conclusion: loading is "a rapid way" to saturate, and "the ingestion of 3 g creatine/day is in the long term likely to be as effective."

So:

  • Loading saturates in 5–7 days. Straight 3–5 g/day reaches the same plateau in 3–4 weeks.
  • The curves converge. Loading confers no lasting advantage.
  • Stop taking it and muscle creatine returns to baseline in about four weeks, however you got there.
  • Typical baseline is around 120 mmol/kg dry matter; the ceiling is around 160.

Loading's only genuine benefit is speed. Its costs are gastrointestinal symptoms and a kilo or two of fast water weight. If you're not competing next week, skip it.


What creatine actually does

Strength and lean mass

This is the well-established part. The ISSN position stand reports supplementation raises muscle phosphocreatine 20–40% and high-intensity exercise performance 10–20%, scaling with how much your muscle creatine actually rose.

(We deliberately haven't quoted a pooled kilogram figure. The two best recent meta-analyses — Burke et al., JSCR 2024, and the 2024 JISSN GRADE dose-response analysis — were paywalled to our research, and we won't publish a number we haven't read.)

The water weight question

Expect roughly 1–2 kg of rapid weight gain in the first week of loading, predominantly intracellular water.

The useful finding is from Ribeiro et al. 2020: intracellular water rose 9.2% on creatine versus 1.6% on placebo, but the ratio of skeletal muscle mass to intracellular water was unchanged in both groups. The water that arrives comes with proportional muscle. It's real weight, it isn't fat, and it isn't subcutaneous puffiness.

Be sceptical of anyone quoting a precise "X% of your gain is water" split — those numbers aren't well supported.

Cognition — weaker than the 2024 headlines suggested

**Sandkühler JF, Kersting X, Faust A, et al. BMC Medicine 2023;21:440 is the sceptic's reference, and it's the best-designed study in the area: preregistered, randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover, n=123**, 5 g/day for 6 weeks.

  • Backward digit span: p=0.064, d=0.17
  • Raven's Advanced Progressive Matrices: p=0.327, d=0.09
  • Eight exploratory tests: no indication of benefit
  • Bayesian analysis gave strong evidence against the large effects previously reported

The trial that generated the headlines was different in an important way. Gordji-Nejad A, Matusch A, Kleedörfer S, et al. Scientific Reports 2024;14:4937: n=15, double-blind crossover, a single 0.35 g/kg dose (about 25 g) during 21 hours of sleep deprivation. Word memory +10.3% (p=0.005), processing speed +17.7% (p=0.002), fatigue −8% (p=0.002), and brain total creatine up 4.2% on MRS (p=0.006). Effects appeared around 3.5 hours and faded by 9.

Read the design before you read the result: fifteen people, one dose, a nine-hour window, sleep-deprived only, and 0.35 g/kg is five times a normal daily dose — not a regimen anyone could sustain on cost or tolerance. There's been no independent replication.

The defensible position: chronic 5 g/day has at best a small, inconsistent effect on memory in healthy, rested, well-fed people. The clearest signals are in sleep-deprived states, older adults, and vegetarians. Don't buy it expecting to think better.

Depression, as an adjunct only

**Lyoo IK, Yoon S, Kim TS, et al. Am J Psychiatry 2012;169(9):937–945.** n=52 women with major depression, 8 weeks, 5 g/day creatine plus escitalopram versus placebo plus escitalopram. Significantly greater improvement in the creatine arm from week 2, sustained to week 8.

A 2025 pilot (n=100 randomised, 60 completers, creatine + CBT) found a PHQ-9 difference of −5.12 (95% CI −7.20 to −3.52) — but with 40% dropout, untracked adherence, and no international trial registration, by the authors' own account.

Promising as an add-on. Small trials. No monotherapy evidence. Not a substitute for treatment, and not an approved use in Australia.

Vegetarians and vegans respond more

**Burke DG, Chilibeck PD, Parise G, et al. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2003;35(11):1946–1955.** n=42 (18 vegetarian), 8 weeks of resistance training.

  • Baseline muscle total creatine: vegetarians 117 vs non-vegetarians 130 mmol/kg dry matter (p<0.05)
  • Vegetarians on creatine gained more muscle creatine, phosphocreatine, lean tissue and total work than non-vegetarians on creatine (p<0.05)
  • Lean tissue +2.4 kg in vegetarians versus +1.9 kg in omnivores

Lower baseline, larger response. If you don't eat meat, this is the single best argument for taking it.

Older adults

**Liu H, Huang Y, Wu X, et al. Eur Rev Aging Phys Act 2025.** 8 RCTs, n=482, aged 50+, creatine plus resistance training versus placebo plus training.

  • Lower-limb strength SMD 0.29 (95% CI 0.00–0.57), p=0.05
  • Lean tissue mass SMD 0.27 (0.02–0.53), p=0.03
  • Upper-limb strength overall not significant (p=0.08), though significant in trials under 32 weeks

Note the effects are small and attenuate in longer trials — which may be adherence as much as biology. And note what the review tested: creatine with resistance training. Creatine without training in older adults is a much weaker proposition.

Women

Genuinely under-covered, so here's what exists. In pre-menopausal women: Vandenberghe et al. (n=20, 10 weeks) found fat-free mass +2.6 kg versus +1.6 kg placebo with 1RM gains 20–25% greater. In post-menopausal women with resistance training, Chilibeck et al.'s 52-week trial found reduced hip bone mineral density loss and increased femoral shaft width — the most interesting women's-health finding in the field. Post-menopausal women without training showed no effect over two years.

On the menstrual cycle: there are no human phase-comparison trials. On pregnancy: no human supplementation trials, animal data only. Anyone telling you otherwise is extrapolating.

One figure to distrust: the widely repeated claim that women have "70–80% lower endogenous creatine stores than men." The review it comes from states that and states women have ~10% higher resting intramuscular creatine, in the same document. The two are incompatible. Don't repeat the 70–80% figure.


Safety: three myths and two real issues

Kidneys — and the practical point everyone should know

Creatine raises your blood creatinine reading without harming your kidneys, and that can look like kidney damage on a blood test.

The mechanism is arithmetic. Creatine converts non-enzymatically to creatinine at a roughly fixed daily rate of about 1.5–2% of the body pool. Supplementing enlarges the pool, so creatinine production rises. Hultman's 1996 study measured it directly: about 2.8 mmol/day of extra creatinine excretion after loading.

Because **eGFR in Australia is calculated from serum creatinine**, a creatine user can get a falsely low eGFR and be flagged for reduced kidney function they don't have. Spillane's ethyl ester arm shows how extreme this can look: serum creatinine 0.95 → 2.68 mg/dL, which in a clinic reads like acute kidney injury.

The evidence on actual renal function: across the reviewed literature, 12 studies showed no increase in serum creatinine and 8 showed an increase that stayed within the normal reference range. The myth traces to a single 1998 case report in a patient with pre-existing renal disease on immunosuppressants.

What to do: if you're having a blood test that includes creatinine or eGFR, tell the doctor you take creatine. If the test is specifically to assess kidney function, consider pausing for about four weeks beforehand — that's the washout. And if you already have kidney disease, ask your doctor before starting.

Hair loss

**van der Merwe J, Brooks NE, Myburgh KH. Clin J Sport Med 2009.** n=20 college rugby players, 25 g/day for 7 days then 5 g/day for 14. DHT rose 56% after loading and stayed about 40% above baseline.

Three things that usually get left out: **no change in total testosterone; DHT stayed within normal clinical limits; and baseline DHT was 23% lower in the creatine group than placebo — so a good part of the "rise" is regression toward the mean. No hair outcome was measured at all.**

Since then: twelve studies on testosterone found no change or physiologically insignificant increases; five measured free testosterone with no increase. A 2025 RCT (Lak et al., JISSN, n=38, 12 weeks) found no significant change in serum DHT or hair density.

In fairness, the American Hair Loss Association criticised that 2025 trial — no genetic screening for androgenetic alopecia, a dated assessment tool, no scalp DHT measurement, and industry-adjacent authorship.

Honest verdict: unsupported, not disproven. One small study measured a hormone, not hair, and has never been reproduced.

Cramping and dehydration

The controlled data go the opposite way to the folklore. Greenwood M, Kreider RB, Melton C, et al. 2003: 72 NCAA football players training in heat (27.3°C, 54.2% humidity) — creatine users had significantly less cramping (p=0.021) and fewer heat illness and dehydration events (p=0.043). Haemodialysis patients given 12 g showed a 60% reduction in cramp frequency.

The ISSN's summary: experimental and clinical research "does not validate the notion that creatine supplementation causes dehydration and muscle cramping." Relevant if you train through an Australian summer.

The real issues

Gastrointestinal upset, and it's dose-dependent. A 2025 randomised trial (n=24, 28 days — note this is currently a preprint, not peer reviewed) found 79.2% of all participants reported some GI symptom, with stomach discomfort significantly worse in the loading arm (p<0.05). Bloating, water retention and stomach discomfort were the most common. Take 3–5 g/day with food, split the dose if needed, and skip loading if you're prone to it.

Contamination, which nobody talks about. Creatine is synthesised from sarcosine and cyanamide, and the process can leave dicyandiamide, dihydrotriazine and creatinine behind.

**Moret S, Prevarin A, Tubaro F. Food Chemistry 2011;126(3):1232–1238 analysed 33 commercial creatine supplements** by HPLC:

  • Creatinine exceeded 100 mg/kg in 44% of samples
  • Dicyandiamide detected in ~15%, up to 8.0 mg/kg
  • Dihydrotriazine above detection limits in ~15%
  • Thiourea: not detected in any sample
  • Heavy metals: only mercury detectable, all below 1 mg/kg; arsenic, cadmium and lead not detected
  • "50% of the products exceeded the maximum level recommended by EFSA for organic contaminants"

That's 2011 data on a European and US sample. We could find no comparable independent assay of the current Australian retail market, which is itself worth saying.

Is Creapure worth it?

Creapure is AlzChem's branded monohydrate, made in Trostberg, Germany. What it actually sells is batch-level analytical control and Cologne List anti-doping screening — not a different molecule and not better absorption. No head-to-head trial of Creapure versus other monohydrate exists, and any claim that it works better is unsupported.

Which makes the answer straightforward: if you're a drug-tested athlete, the documented provenance is worth real money. If you're not, what you want is any product with a current, batch-specific, third-party certificate of analysis. Bulk Nutrients, for instance, publishes COAs from Australian labs while stating openly that its raw amino acids are sourced from China — that transparency is worth more than a brand name.

Context for how rare that is: a 2022 survey of 175 creatine products found only 8% advertised third-party certification.


Gummies

The chemistry first, because it explains everything

Creatine is extremely stable as a dry crystal and unstable in water. **Uzzan M, Nechrebeki J, Zhou P, Labuza TP. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2009;35(8)** measured the conversion to creatinine by water activity and temperature at pH 4.0 — which is roughly a gummy's pH, since gummies are acidified with citric acid:

TemperatureLow moisture (a_w 0.31)Moderate (a_w 0.49)High (a_w 0.98)
4°C2,529 days1,409 days368 days
23°C182 days132 days43 days
35°C29 days24 days12 days

Crystalline creatine, by contrast, showed no degradation at all up to a_w 0.68, and 0.11% after three months at 23°C even at a_w 0.90.

A half-life measured in weeks at room temperature, in an acidified moist matrix, is fundamentally hard to reconcile with a shelf-stable 5 g label claim. Gummies are cooked warm and then warehoused. It's a hard formulation problem, not a given.

What the testing found

NOW Foods, March 2024. NOW bought 12–13 creatine gummy brands and assayed them by HPLC. Six passed. Six failed with little to no creatine — and every failing product contained detectable creatinine, consistent with degradation rather than simple underdosing. NOW's quality director noted they could not find a third-party lab equipped to test gummies at all.

(Caveats worth carrying: NOW is a competing powder manufacturer, individual values weren't released, and at least one named brand disputed the result citing its own accredited lot testing.)

SuppCo, June 2025 — this round has numbers. Eleven products (5 powders, 6 gummies) assayed at an ISO 17025-accredited lab:

  • All five powders passed, 98–101% purity
  • Gummies that passed: Force Factor (6.3 g measured against a 5 g label), Create (4.59 g against 4.5 g)
  • Gummies that failed: one at 0.09% of a standard dose (you'd need about 2,000 gummies for 5 g), one at 0.50%, and two with zero detectable creatine
  • Even the passing gummies showed significant creatinine

The verdict: gummies aren't a different form of creatine — the good ones contain monohydrate. The problem is formulation and quality control, it's brand- and lot-specific, and no mainstream gummy carries public batch-level assay data.


The Australian regulatory bit, which almost nobody states correctly

Creatine is both a food and a therapeutic good here, depending on the dosage form — and the TGA's sports supplement declaration is what changed that.

Under the declaration that commenced 30 November 2020, a sports supplement is a therapeutic good if it makes performance claims and either contains a scheduled or WADA-prohibited substance, or — from 30 November 2023 — is "supplied in the dosage form of a tablet, capsule or pill."

What that means:

  • Creatine powders remain foods, regulated by FSANZ. Creatine isn't scheduled and isn't WADA-prohibited, so the ingredient limb doesn't catch it.
  • Creatine tablets, capsules and pills marketed for sports performance have been therapeutic goods since 30 November 2023 — they need ARTG listing and must meet medicine manufacturing and labelling requirements. So HCl capsules sit in a different regulatory class from HCl powder.
  • Gummies are the live ambiguity. The TGA's declaration and fact sheet don't mention gummies, pastilles or soft chews at all, and whether a gummy is a "tablet, capsule or pill" is unresolved on the face of the instrument. Don't assume any TGA oversight of gummy label accuracy.

What it costs

Australian prices, 1 October 2026. Supplement prices move weekly. The right-hand column is the one that matters — cost per 5 g of actual creatine, after correcting for the mass fractions at the top of this page.

ProductPrice$ per 5 g creatine
Bulk monohydrate, 1 kg (cheapest listing)$34.97$0.20
Bulk Nutrients monohydrate, 1 kg$48.00$0.27
Musashi monohydrate, 350 g$30.99$0.50
Bulk Nutrients monohydrate, 250 g$24.00$0.55
Switch Nutrition Creapure, 500 g$69.95$0.80
Bulk Nutrients creatine HCl, 120 × 750 mg caps$29.00$2.06 (needs 8–9 capsules/day)
The Gummy Co gummies, 30 serves$64.95$2.17
SUP Creatine Gummies, 35 ct$19.99$2.86
  • Creapure: about 4× the cheapest bulk monohydrate. That buys documented purity and anti-doping screening, not a better molecule.
  • HCl capsules: about 10× — and to get a dose-equivalent 5 g you'd swallow eight or nine capsules a day, which rather demolishes the "convenient smaller dose" pitch. At the recommended two capsules, you're paying $0.48/day for under a quarter of a standard dose.
  • Gummies: 11–14×, with the label-accuracy and degradation problems on top.

What to actually buy

Creatine monohydrate powder, 3–5 g a day, taken whenever suits you. Micronised if you want it to mix better. From a brand that publishes batch-specific certificates of analysis.

Skip the loading phase unless you need saturation this week — you'll get to the same place in three to four weeks without the GI symptoms.

Pay the Creapure premium only if you're drug-tested. Skip HCl, ethyl ester, buffered, nitrate and liquid entirely — not because they're dangerous, but because you're paying more for either less creatine or an unproven claim. And treat gummies as a convenience product with a real chance of not containing what the label says.


Frequently asked

Is creatine HCl better than monohydrate? No trial shows it is. The few head-to-head studies found no significant between-group differences, none measured muscle creatine, and HCl is 78% creatine by mass against monohydrate's 88% — so the typical 1.5 g HCl dose delivers about 1.17 g of creatine, under a quarter of a standard dose. It is more soluble, but solubility has never been linked to better muscle uptake or performance.

Do I need to do a loading phase? No. Loading saturates muscle in 5–7 days; 3–5 g a day gets you to the same plateau in 3–4 weeks, and the curves converge. Loading's only benefit is speed, and its cost is more gastrointestinal upset and a faster kilo or two of water weight.

Does creatine damage your kidneys? No, in people with healthy kidneys — but it does raise your blood creatinine reading, because creatine converts to creatinine at a fixed rate and supplementing enlarges the pool. Since eGFR is calculated from creatinine, this can look like reduced kidney function on a blood test when nothing is wrong. Tell your doctor you take it, and consider pausing four weeks before a test specifically assessing kidney function.

Does creatine cause hair loss? There is no evidence that it does. The claim comes from one 2009 study of 20 rugby players that measured DHT, not hair, found levels stayed within the normal range, and started with a creatine group whose baseline DHT was already 23% lower than placebo. It has never been replicated, and a 2025 trial found no change in DHT or hair density.

Are creatine gummies worth it? On current evidence, no. Independent testing in 2024 and 2025 found several brands containing little or no creatine, with detectable creatinine indicating degradation — and the chemistry explains why: creatine's half-life in an acidified, moist matrix is measured in weeks, not years. They also cost 11–14 times more per gram of creatine than powder.

Should women take creatine? The evidence in women is thinner than in men but points the same way, with gains in strength and lean mass in pre-menopausal women and a notable bone-density finding in post-menopausal women who also resistance train. There are no human trials on menstrual cycle phase and none on pregnancy. Be sceptical of the widely repeated "women have 70–80% lower creatine stores" claim — the review it comes from contradicts itself on that point.


Last reviewed 1 October 2026. Mass fractions are calculated from standard atomic weights. Prices are Australian retail at the date of review and change frequently. This page is general information, not medical advice — if you have kidney disease, speak to your doctor before supplementing.